Is Your Portfolio Really Diversified? Use AI to Find Hidden Overlap

In partnership with

Your Portfolio May Be Less Diversified Than You Think

Different funds can quietly lead back to the same handful of companies.

✍️ Editor’s Note

Owning several funds can create a reassuring sense of diversification. But different ticker symbols don’t always represent different investments.

A portfolio containing a broad-market fund, a technology fund, a growth fund, and an AI-themed fund may look diversified on the surface. Underneath, those funds could hold many of the same companies.

In today’s issue, we’re using AI for something more personal than finding the next hot stock: uncovering the risks already hiding inside your portfolio.

Let’s open the vault.

Some teams never seem to stop moving. They're on Attio, the agentic CRM.

Every customer signal is captured in one shared context layer, always current and compounding. Agents and workflows build pipeline, chase every buying signal, and move deals forward, an always-on revenue engine running alongside your team.

With Attio, you’ll get:

• Leads automatically prioritised and routed to the right rep

• Expansion and risk signals caught the moment they land

• Follow-ups written in your voice, already there when you arrive

Teams like Parallel, Turbopuffer, and Wordsmith build on Attio. Are you one of them?

Get started now

🧬 The Diversification Illusion

Imagine an investor owns four exchange-traded funds:

• A broad U.S. market ETF

• A large-cap growth ETF

• A technology ETF

• An artificial-intelligence ETF

That sounds like exposure to four different strategies.

Now imagine that the largest positions in all four funds include many of the same technology companies. Instead of owning four independent baskets, the investor may have repeatedly purchased overlapping versions of one basket.

This is called portfolio overlap.

Overlap isn’t automatically bad. An investor may intentionally want greater exposure to certain companies or industries. The problem begins when that concentration happens without the investor realizing it.

🔍 Why Fund Names Can Be Misleading

An ETF’s name describes its general mandate - not necessarily the practical role it plays in your portfolio.

A fund labeled “artificial intelligence” might hold semiconductor companies, cloud providers, software developers, automation businesses, or companies that receive only a small portion of their revenue from AI.

A “growth” fund may also be heavily exposed to technology. A broad-market index can place substantial weight on the market’s largest companies.

As a result, three funds with different names can respond similarly when the same group of underlying stocks rises or falls.

The better question isn’t:

It’s:

🧮 A Simple Overlap Example

Suppose Fund A places 8% of its assets in Company X, while Fund B places 6% in that same company.

If you invest equal amounts in both funds, Company X represents approximately 7% of that two-fund portfolio.

Add a third fund with another large position in Company X, and the exposure grows—even though you never purchased the stock directly.

The same issue can occur across an entire group of companies. Several ETFs may repeatedly expose you to:

• The same mega-cap stocks

• The semiconductor industry

• High-growth companies

• U.S. technology businesses

• Companies sensitive to interest rates

• Businesses dependent on continued AI spending

The risk isn’t visible from the number of holdings alone. A fund might own 100 stocks while concentrating much of its value in its largest ten positions.

🤖 Use AI to X-Ray Your Portfolio

AI can help organize fund holdings, identify repeated positions, and explain where risks may be concentrated.

Before using the prompt below, gather the latest holdings for each ETF from the fund provider’s official website. A downloadable CSV file is ideal.

Do not upload brokerage statements, account numbers, balances, or personal identifying information. You only need ticker symbols, portfolio percentages, and public fund-holdings data.

📋 The Portfolio-Overlap Prompt

✅ How to Verify the AI’s Results

AI can make arithmetic errors, misread percentages, or combine companies incorrectly. Verify the analysis before using it:

1. Confirm that every holdings list came directly from the fund provider and includes an effective date.

2. Check whether each percentage was entered as a whole percentage or decimal. Confusing 8% with 0.08 can ruin the calculation.

3. Manually recalculate the five largest combined positions.

4. Confirm that different share classes or ticker symbols were not incorrectly treated as separate companies.

5. Compare the AI’s totals with a reputable portfolio-overlap or fund-analysis tool.

6. Check whether the fund uses derivatives, swaps, or other instruments that aren’t captured by a basic holdings comparison.

7. Repeat the analysis periodically because ETF holdings and portfolio weights change.

Treat the AI output as an organizational aid - not as an audited portfolio report.

🚨 Four Concentrations Worth Checking

1. 🏢 Company Concentration

How much of your total portfolio ultimately depends on each company?

A stock held by several funds can become one of your largest positions without appearing separately in your brokerage account.

2. 🧩 Industry Concentration

Different companies can still depend on the same economic forces. Owning several semiconductor businesses provides company diversification, but not necessarily industry diversification.

3. 🎯 Strategy Concentration

Technology, growth, innovation, and AI funds may use different labels while pursuing similar opportunities.

4. 🌎 Geographic Concentration

A portfolio of several U.S.-focused funds may provide little exposure to international markets, even if the companies sell products globally.

🛠️ What to Do With the Findings

Discovering overlap doesn’t mean you should immediately sell anything.

Instead, ask:

• Is this concentration intentional?

• Does it match my time horizon and risk tolerance?

• Would these holdings likely decline together?

• Am I paying multiple fund fees for similar exposure?

• What important assets, industries, or regions are missing?

The goal is not to eliminate every repeated holding. Some overlap is unavoidable, and some may support your strategy.

The goal is to make sure your portfolio reflects a deliberate decision rather than an accidental collection of fund names.

🔐 The Vault’s Takeaway

Diversification should be measured by the investments and risks you actually own - not by the number of tickers displayed in your account.

AI can help you look through the outer packaging of your funds and reveal the companies, industries, and themes underneath. That makes it useful not only for researching new opportunities, but also for understanding what you already have.

Sometimes the most valuable investing discovery isn’t the next stock to buy.

It’s the risk you didn’t know you were already taking.

Vaulting Your Wealth Forward,
– T. D. Thompson

AI Investing Vault

The content above is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any financial instruments. Trading and investing involve significant risk of loss, and past performance is not indicative of future results. Always consult with a licensed financial advisor or conduct your own research before making any investment decisions. Use of AI tools and strategies mentioned above is at your own discretion and risk. AI Investing Vault may receive compensation if you purchase tools or services mentioned in this email, at no additional cost to you.